CLIMATE CRIMINALS: ENI and Shell, keep the fossil fuels in the ground! We don’t want your false forests!

CLIMATE CRIMINALS: ENI and Shell, keep the fossil fuels in the ground! We don’t want your false forests!

13 May 2019

A new strategy put forward by fossil fuel corporations to plant trees as ‘compensation’ for climate change is not only a greenwashing gimmick, but a dangerous tactic that could exacerbate the problems caused by fossil fuel exploitation.

Fossil fuel giants ENI (Italy) and Shell (the Netherlands) have announced reforestation programmes as compensation for carbon emissions, in a push to greenwash a corporate model that has caused widespread environmental devastation, land grabbing and the destruction of livelihoods. The two companies are responsible for environmental disasters and crimes as a result of their fossil fuel activities in Nigeria and many other places across the globe.

ENI is currently undergoing a massive operation to exploit new gas reserves in northern Mozambique. For years, the company has engaged in extremely damaging gas flaring in the Niger delta – a practice which is still underway, long after ENI promised to quit gas flaring at its 2011 Annual General Meeting. Only last year, the Nigerian Ikebiri community took ENI to court for pollution of their lands and water. The company is also on trial in Basilicata – a small region of southern Italy nicknamed the Italian Texas because of its oil activities – where ENI stands accused of illegally dumping hazardous waste into the environment.

Shell is one of the world’s top 10 climate polluters, and since the 1980s has operated in the knowledge that burning oil and gas would have disastrous consequences for the climate (i). Yet the company continues to spend billions of dollars seeking out new oil and gas fields, and spends a further $49 million each year lobbying for fossil-fuel friendly policies (ii). Shell has been involved in, and their executives were probably aware of, numerous murders, tortures and rapes carried out by paramilitary organisations in Nigeria during the 1990s. Its current activities in Groningen, the Netherlands, are the cause of earthquakes that are destroying peoples’ homes (iii).

Now, ENI and Shell are pushing a new and dangerous tactic. ENI has announced plans to plant 8.1 million hectares of trees in Mozambique, South Africa, Ghana, and Zimbabwe (iv). CEO Claudio Descalzi announced ENI’s objective “to achieve net zero emissions in our upstream business by 2030,” in the company’s strategy update on 15 March 2019. Meanwhile, Shell has presented its plan, launching in 2019, to reduce its “net carbon footprint by 2%-3%”. The plan will include reforestation of false forests, with the company offering carbon credits to its customers so that they may offset their emissions (v). Shell is also pushing controversial schemes such as Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD+), which not only fail to reduce greenhouse emissions, but lead to the violation of environmental and human rights, the exacerbation of corruption and the corporate capture of vital climate funds. REDD+ projects reduce nature to a commodity to be bought and sold, and local communities are either expelled from their land in the name of ‘preservation’ or employed as private conservationists, while traditional land management practices disappear. Meanwhile, by focusing on the community’s responsibility for deforestation, the central role of large corporations and the state as the primary actors in environmental destruction is underplayed.

The protection of critical natural ecosystems such as mangroves, forests, dunes, wetlands is crucial, and will help the planet to naturally absorb carbon emissions, while also providing livelihoods to local communities and warding off extreme weather events. However, strategies put forward by Shell and ENI will do nothing to contribute to these aims – far from it.

Solving the climate crisis requires deep, urgent and immediate emissions cuts, meaning that dirty and harmful energy must be stopped at source, and cannot simply be ‘compensated’ elsewhere in the world. Fossil fuels must be left in the ground, but instead, ENI and Shell do not even pretend to deal with this reality so far, investing billions in the quest to find further reserves.

We write this statement as the impacts of Cyclone Idai are still being felt. The cyclone and related flooding in the last few weeks has devastated huge parts of Mozambique, Zimbabwe and Malawi, claiming thousands of lives and affecting millions more. Those impacted are people who did not create the climate crisis, while ENI and Shell are among the perpetrators of the crisis. The people of the world, especially the poorest and most vulnerable who suffer the worst effects of climate change, cannot afford any further fossil fuel expansion.

Truly addressing the climate crisis means achieving ‘zero emissions’ NOT ‘net zero’ emissions. A ‘net zero’ goal allows polluters such as ENI and Shell to keep polluting on the pretext that they may use artificial plantations to ‘suck’ carbon out of the air in other parts of the world. From a climate justice perspective, this strategy is completely flawed. There is no guarantee that tree plantations can secure carbon offsetting in the long term. Plantations do not and can never compensate for the destruction of the natural world: they reduce biodiversity, lead to exhausted soils and absorb only a fraction of the CO2 taken in by real forests.

Furthermore, through this plan, ENI and Shell intend to introduce tree plantations to an area larger than the whole of Northern Italy, ENI’s homeland – or double the size of the Netherlands, from where Shell hails. This raises serious questions. Where on Earth will ENI plant these 8.1 million hectares of fake forests? Where is the land to do so, and whose land will they grab to do this planting? What would ENI say if the tables were turned, and Africans wanted all of Northern Italy to plant trees?

There is no unused land available at this scale, which means millions more people will be affected, through the loss of their land, homes and forests. Areas teeming with biodiversity will become monoculture plantations. This will undoubtedly have calamitous impacts on the food sovereignty and rights of people across Africa.

Neither ENI nor Shell have the right to impose such tree plantations on the lands of local communities and indigenous peoples. For generations, communities have taken care of their forests, often fighting off their own governments to retain ownership and control. Many communities are already resisting dirty energy, agro-commodities, infrastructure and large commercial projects that drive deforestation. The new spectre of corporate climate ‘compensation’ schemes headed by the dirtiest fossil fuel corporations is a ludicrous affront, and one which will be fought wherever it rears its head.

Climate justice requires that ENI and Shell immediately cut their emissions at source. Since the industrial revolution, the fossil fuel industry has grown rich through the exploitation of people and nature, leading to large-scale and irreversible destruction of the atmosphere. As such, ENI and Shell owe a colossal climate debt to those bearing the brunt of the impacts of climate change. At the same time, deforestation poses a grievous risk to people and the planet. If we are to stand any chance of halting the inter-related crises of climate change and biodiversity loss, fossil fuels and deforestation must both come to an end.

To stop causing the climate crisis, ENI and Shell MUST stop fossil fuels and harmful energy at source. No more land grabs in Africa or anywhere!

No fossil fuels! No dirty and harmful energy! No to false forests! Yes to real reductions, No to net zero! ENI and Shell, Stop your emissions at source!

References:

(i) https://en.milieudefensie.nl/climate-case-shell
(ii) https://leftfootforward.org/2019/03/report-uk-firms-are-the-biggest-spenders-in-global-climate-change-lobbying/(iii) https://www.foei.org/news/these-eight-scandals-prove-shells-long-history-of-contempt-for-people-and-planet(iv) https://www.ft.com/content/7c4d944e-470d-11e9-b168-96a37d002cd3(v) https://www.shell.com/media/news-and-media-releases/2019/shell-invests-in-nature-to-tackle-co2-emissions.html

 

SIGNED BY:

1. Anabela Lemos, Justiça Ambiental/ Friends of the Earth Mozambique
2. Bobby Peek, groundwork/ Friends of the Earth South Africa
3. Farai Maguwu, Centre for Natural Resource Governance, Zimbabwe
4. Nnimmo Bassey and Anabela Lemos, No REDD in Africa Network (NRAN)
5. Giulia Franchi, Re:Common, Italy
6. Karin Nansen, Chair, Friends of the Earth International

 

STATEMENT ENDORSED BY:

S. No.	NAME OF THE PERSON	NAME OF THE ORGANIZATION SIGNING ON
1	Ricardo Navarro	CESTA/ Friends of the Earth El Salvador
2	Maggie Mapondera	WoMin African Alliance
3	Martin Galea De Giovanni	Friends of the Earth Malta
4	Helen La Trobe	Friends of the Earth Ghana
5	Richard Dixon	Friends of the Earth Scotland
6	Víctor Barro	Amigos de la Tierra (España)
7	Janet Solomon	Oceans Not Oil
8	Desmond Dsa	South Durban Community Environmental Alliance
9	Nanna Clifforth	NOAH Friends of the Earth Denmark
10	Tom BK Goldtooth	Indigenous Environmental Network
11	Frank Muramuzi	Friends of the Earth Uganda / NAPE
12	Kureeba David	Regional Coordinator Friends the Earth Africa
13	Maria Selva Ortiz	REDES – FoE Uruguay
14	Camila Rolando Mazzuca	EnvJustice
15	Sam Mucunguzi	Coordinator- Citizens’ Concern Africa -(CICOA) Uganda
16	Michelle Pressend	Environmental Humanities South (EHS), UCT
17	Ivonne Yanez	Accion Ecologica, Ecuador
18	Almuth Ernsting	Biofuelwatch, UK/US
19	Martin Vilela	Bolivian Platform on Climate Change
20	Cindy Wiesner	Grassroots Global Justice Alliance (US)
21	Pennie Opal Plant	Idle No More SF Bay
22	Hemantha Withanage	Centre for Environmental Justice/ Friends of the Earth Sri Lanka
23	Pascoe Sabido	Corporate Europe Observatory
24	Yago Martínez Álvarez	Ecologistas en Acción, Spain
25	Alejandro Aleman	Centro Humboldt, Nicaragua
26	Mercia Andrews	Rural Women’s Assembly (southern Africa)
27	Lungisa Huna	Trust for Community Outreach and Education (TCOE) (South Africa)
28	Larry Lohmann	The Corner House, UK
29	Antonio Zambrano	Movimiento Ciudadano frente al Cambio Climático – MOCICC, Perú
30	Choony Kim	Korea Federation for Environmental Movement (KFEM/ FoE Korea)
31	Juan Pablo Orrego	ONG Ecosistemas – Chile
32	Edwin Mumbere Fanta	Kasese youth and women clean energy club, Uganda
33	Logan Moodley	KZNSFF
34	Ayumi Fukakusa	FoE Japan
35	Bori Yordanova	Za Zemiata – Friends of the Earth Bulgaria
36	Luca Saltalamacchia	Studio Legale Saltalamacchia
37	Simon Taylor	Global Witness
38	Simon Counsell	Rainforest Foundation UK
39	Cadmus Atake-Enade	Health of Mother Earth Foundation, Nigeria
40	Marija Mileta	Zelena akcija/ FoE Croatia
41	Dickens Kamugisha	Africa Institute for Energy Governance (AFIEGO), Uganda
42	Anna Barkered	Latinamerikagrupperna / Solidarity Sweden-Latin America
43	Teresa Perez	World Rainforest Movement
44	Yoram Banyenzaki	Guild Presidents Forum on Governance (GPFOG), Uganda
45	Eriel Deranger	Indigenous Climate Action, Canada & member of the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation
46	Khalid Mather	WildoceansSA
47	Judy Bell	FrackFreeSA
48	Alejandra Porras	COECOCEIBA – Amigos de la Tierra Costa Rica
49	Eduardo Giesen	Colectivo VientoSur – Chile
50	Opio Christopher	Oil Refinery Residents Association, ORRA – Uganda
51	Ana Maria R. Nemenzo	WomanHealth Philippines
52	Alnoor Ladha	The Rules Foundation
53	Maxime Combes	Attac France
54	Niko van Rensburg	Animalia Learning Center, Assagay, KZN, SA
55	Ncobile Nkosi	South African Youth Climate Change Coalition, South Africa, NWU, MP
56	Wolfgang Kuhlmann	ARA, Germany
57	Godwin Ojo	Environmental Rights Action/ Friends of the Earth Nigeria
58	Bishop Geoff Davies/ Vainola Makan	SAFCEI – Southern African Faith Communities’ Environment Institute
59	Evelyn Schönheit	Forum Ökologie & Papier, Germany
60	Louise Lindfors/ Anna Ushamba	Afrikagrupperna
61	Silvia Ribeiro	ETC Group
62	Khulekani Magwaza	South African Youth Climate Change Coalition (SAYCCC)
63	Alphonse Maindo	Tropenbos DRC
64	Stella Jegher	Pro Natura / Friends of the Earth Switzerland
65	Natalia Salvatico	Amigos de la Tierra Argentina
66	Robert Anderson	Noordhoek Environmental Action Group, South Africa
67	Kwami Kpondzo	Global Forest Coalition
68	Amegadze Kokou	Les Amis de la Terre-Togo
69	Mikael Sundström	Chair, Jordens Vänner – Friends of the Earth Sweden
70	Dorothy Guerrero	Global Justice Now (UK)
71	Rose Williams	Biowatch South Africa
72	Glen Tyler-Davies	350Africa.org
73	Fernando Campos Costa	FoE Brasil
74	Vanessa Black	Earthlife Africa Durban branch
75	Ernst-Christoph Stolper	BUND – Friends of the Earth Germany
76	Robert Jereski	New York Climate Action Group
77	Olga Senova	Russian Social Ecological Union – Friends of the Earth Russia
78	Howard Wood OBE	COAST, 2015 Goldman Award Recipient Scotland
79	Ka Hsaw Wa	EarthRights International
80	Rossano Ercolini	Zero Waste europe-Zero Waste Italy
81	Àlex Guillamón	Entrepueblos/ Entrepobles/ Entrepobos/ Herriarte
82	Jorge Varela Márquez	Ambiente, Desarrollo y Capacitación
83	Louise Colvin	Ward Environmental Affairs Bluff South Africa
84	Ode Rakhman	WALHI / FoE Indonesia
85	Syeda Rizwana Hasan	BELA / FoE Bangladesh
86	Kirant Kamal Samarung	Kirant Indigenous Samarung Sangpang, Indigenous Knowledge and Peoples Network SWBC Nepal
87	Sviatoslav Zabelin	Socio-ecological union international
88	Ikal Angelei	Friends of Lake Turkana (FoLT)
89	Meena Raman	Sahabat Alam Malaysia (Friends of the Earth Malaysia)
90	Juliette Renaud	Amis de la Terre France (Friends of the Earth France)
91	Sylvain Angerand	Canopée Forêts Vivantes – France
92	Christophe Murroccu	Mouvement Ecologique (FoELux)
93	Živa Kavka Gobbo	Focus Association for Sustainable Development, Slovenia
94	Bruno van PETEGHEM	Association Toxicologie-Chimie – FRANCE
95	Laura greco	A Sud, Italy
96	Prafulla Samantara	Lokshakti Abhiyan, India
97	Wendy Flannery	Friends of the Earth Brisbane, Australia
98	Katharine Lu / Karen Orenstein	Friends of the Earth U.S.
99	Karen Pickett	Earth First!, Calif., B.A. Coalition for Headwaters
100	Mary de Haas	KZN Monitor
101	Kristina Salmi/ Jarrah Kollei	Friends of the Earth Finland
102	Jennifer Redner	American Jewish World Service (AJWS)
103	Beatriz Felipe Pérez	Enginyeria Sense Fronteres
104	James Whitehead	Forest Peoples Programme
105	Joan Deare	Amnesty International Durban, South Africa
106	Andrew Bennie	Sustaining the Wild Coast
107	Makoma Lekalakala	Earthlife Africa Johannesburg
108	Ivonne Ramos	Saramanta Warmikuna Women’s Network
109	Helena Paul	EcoNexus

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ end ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~